Energy market data Markets & map →
Article

PJM's capacity shortfall: who pays for data center load

November 11, 2026 | Energy markets

PJM's July capacity auction cleared at the price cap and still fell short of its reliability requirement. Here is what the primary sources say, and what remains open.

1 Key points

  • PJM's 2028/2029 capacity auction cleared at the $325 per MW-day cap and was still 6,831 MW short of the reliability requirement.
  • PJM's independent market monitor attributes the tight supply largely to forecast data center load and estimates the price effect at $6.3 billion in this auction.
  • In October, FERC rejected the bulk of PJM's filing on how to connect large loads. A commissioner's concurrence says states should set curtailment priorities.
  • The next auction is scheduled for December. The open question is who bears the cost of new supply.

2 What happened

PJM Interconnection serves 67 million people in 13 states and Washington, D.C. On July 14, 2026, it announced results for its 2028/2029 Base Residual Auction. It secured 138,318 MW of capacity at $325 per MW-day. That is the FERC-approved cap and 2.5% below the prior auction's cap of $333.44.

Cleared supply times price comes to $16.4 billion. PJM notes this is not the total cost to customers, because load hedged through self-supply or bilateral contracts is not exposed to the auction price.

With Fixed Resource Requirement regions counted, committed supply was 6,831 MW below PJM's reliability requirement. That requirement is built on a one-loss-of-load-event-in-10-years standard. PJM says a shortfall does not mean it cannot serve load. It means thinner reserves and more risk. The reserve margin for the delivery year is 14.7%. The last two auctions were the first in PJM's history where the whole region fell short.

PJM's board letter of July 27 gives its own diagnosis: new large loads are forecast to grow by an estimated 70 GW by 2038, while about 15 GW of generation has retired since 2022.

Capacity cleared138,318 MW

Clearing price$325 per MW-day (the cap)

Cleared value$16.4 billion

Shortfall6,831 MW

Reserve margin14.7%

Source: PJM news release, July 14, 2026, and PJM Inside Lines, July 27, 2026.

3 What the market monitor says

Monitoring Analytics, PJM's Independent Market Monitor, published its analysis on October 30. Its figures come from sensitivity scenarios. The monitor states they are not forecasts or predictions of any future auction.

  • PJM's load forecast for the auction included 21,470 MW of existing and forecast data center load. Of that, 16,436 MW was forecast growth above what was already embedded.
  • Removing all of it, the monitor estimates auction revenues would have been $6,267,819,123 lower. That is about 38% of the $16.4 billion total.
  • Summed over the last four auctions, the monitor puts the data center effect at $29,368,774,465.
  • Its recommendation: require new data center load to bring its own new generation, so forecast uncertainty does not fall on other customers.

"There would have been no shortfall but for the forecast data center load." - Independent Market Monitor, October 30, 2026

This is one party's analysis. It rests on a load forecast, not metered load, and other market participants weigh the evidence differently.

4 What regulators said

On October 9, FERC acted on PJM's large-load filing (Docket ER26-3515). In a concurrence, Commissioner Rosner wrote that he agreed "with the decision to reject the bulk of PJM's filing." The filing proposed to curtail some large loads early in emergency conditions, before demand response is used.

Rosner raised a market-design concern. Because curtailable load would be left out of the capacity demand curve, he wrote, the market could signal "more than enough capacity while the region sheds thousands of megawatts of demand on an involuntary basis." He also wrote that states need to establish clear rules for which customers are curtailed first.

Not yet verified. This article quotes the concurrence, a primary source. It does not describe the full order, which we have not read. Secondary reports exist but are not used here.

5 What to watch

  • The 2029/2030 auction. The monitor reports it is scheduled for December 9 to 15, 2026, with the same price cap and floor, and expects a data center cost impact of about the same size as in the last four auctions.
  • The Reliability Backstop Procurement (RBP), PJM's planned one-time purchase of new capacity. FERC accepted the original framework for filing on September 29, suspended it for five months until February 28, 2027, subject to refund, and opened further proceedings on cost allocation, collateral and exit rules. That was not unconditional final approval.
  • PJM submitted revised rules on October 29 and refiled them on November 9 in substantively identical form, changing the filing classification. It requests a FERC decision by January 29, 2027, and a February 28 effective date for most rules. These are requested dates, not a new FERC decision. The monitor says procurement now follows the December auction.
  • The amount procured is not fixed at the historical auction shortfall. The revised proposal allows qualifying new capacity contracted with large loads and qualifying peak-shaving participation to reduce the procurement target. Those offsets have eligibility and evidence requirements.
  • State decisions on curtailment priority and cost allocation.

6 Analysis

Our interpretation, not a forecast. This section is analysis and educational speculation. It does not predict prices or outcomes.

A price cap limits what a shortage costs in any one auction. It also limits the signal that tells developers to build. If curtail-first connection rules are largely off the table, the routes left look like bilateral deals between large loads and new supply, plus state rules. If that holds, contracted new supply may be a more useful number to track than the headline clearing price.

For energy-intensive commercial and industrial users in PJM states, the effect is indirect. How much of the capacity cost reaches a given customer depends on how its supply is structured and when it was priced. That is a question for each business's own contracts and utility.

7 About Xyzenrgy

Xyzenrgy publishes energy market research for commercial and industrial businesses. Questions, corrections or topic suggestions: [email protected]

Sources checked November 11, 2026.

Back to Insights Start a conversation